- Three ways Delaware reviews a holder
- What SB 13 changed in 2017
- The court cases behind the rules
- The VDA invitation and the 90-day clock
- Inside the Secretary of State VDA
- Verified reports and compliance reviews
- The examination, step by step
- The expedited examination
- VDA or examination: side by side
- Findings, appeal and records
- Questions holders ask
- Sources
Delaware Code title 12, chapter 11, subchapter II, as amended through 2024. Details and quotes below.
Three ways Delaware reviews a holder
Under the Supreme Court's priority rules, Delaware takes the property its companies hold with no owner address, wherever they do business. The Secretary of State's FAQ puts it bluntly: “all Delaware legal entities are subject to the unclaimed property laws of the State, regardless of whether it conducts business in Delaware.” Delaware enforces that claim actively. The Department of Finance's enforcement page names three programs: “the Secretary of State's Voluntary Disclosure Agreement (VDA) Program, the OUP's § 1170 Compliance Program and the OUP's Examination Program”. The first is run by the Secretary of State; the other two by the Office of Unclaimed Property for the State Escheator.
They connect. “For companies that do not complete a requested Verified Report or Compliance Review or choose not to participate in the VDA program, the OUP may assign them to an unclaimed property examination.” The Delaware state page covers the March 1 report, dormancy and due diligence; this page covers what happens when Delaware comes asking. The Delaware VDA invitation letter page explains the letter itself.
What SB 13 changed in 2017
Delaware rewrote its law in Senate Bill 13, “Approved February 2, 2017” (81 Del. Laws c. 1), after years of litigation over its audits. The main changes a holder meets today:
- Invitation first. The State Escheator “shall not initiate any new examination of records or an investigation of any person under this section unless the person has first been notified in writing by the Secretary of State that the person may enter into an unclaimed property voluntary disclosure agreement” (1172(a)), with exceptions for whistleblower tips, joint exams with other states, holders that cannot use the VDA and holders that ignore a compliance review (1172(d)).
- A 10-year reach. No examination “more than 10 years after the duty arose under this chapter”, counted from the earlier of the exam notice or the VDA invitation, unless the holder filed a fraudulent or wilful misrepresentation (1172(h)). For 5-year property that is about 15 transaction years.
- Records rule. Holders keep records 10 years after a report (1145). Before 2017 there was none; the Third Circuit noted that “The UPL did not have a records retention requirement prior to the 2017 amendments.”
- Estimation only without records. If the holder filed its reports and kept its records, “The examination may not be based upon an estimate unless the holder expressly consents in a record to the use of an estimate.” (1172(f)(2)).
- Contract auditor limits (1178): no firm may get more than half the examinations, contracts run 5 years at most, and pay is hourly for holders incorporated in Delaware, except securities and life insurance accounts.
- Court review. A holder can take the findings to the Court of Chancery within 90 days (1179).
The court cases behind the rules
The reform followed federal suits by holders. They are worth knowing because the same arguments come back in any estimate dispute.
| Case | What happened | What it means for a holder |
|---|---|---|
| Temple-Inland, Inc. v. Cook (D. Del. June 28, 2016) | Delaware “audited plaintiff for deficiencies in reporting and escheating unclaimed property for the previous 22 year time period”; the holder had destroyed older records under its policy. Estimates for the missing years used items addressed to other states, so “then a holder is being compelled to escheat the same estimated property to two states”. | The court found the State “engaged in a game of ‘gotcha’ that shocks the conscience”, but did not ban estimation: “The court does not, however, agree with plaintiff that estimation could never meet this burden.” |
| Plains All American Pipeline v. Cook (3d Cir. Aug. 9, 2017) | A holder challenged an audit run by a contingent-fee firm. The court noted that “unclaimed property has become Delaware’s third-largest source of revenue”. | The due process claim was ripe: “all Plains must show is that it was required to submit a dispute to a self-interested party”. |
| Marathon Petroleum v. Secretary of Finance (3d Cir. Dec. 4, 2017) | Gift card subsidiaries challenged an audit that asked for decades of records. | Holders can sue under the priority rules: the court disagreed that “private parties cannot invoke federal common law to challenge a state’s authority to escheat property”. It warned against demands “so obviously pretextual or insatiable” and against using an audit “as a pass for abusive auditing practices”. |
| Office Depot v. Secretary of Finance (3d Cir. Jan. 22, 2018) | The same question for another gift card subsidiary. | Followed Marathon: “private parties have standing to challenge a state’s authority to conduct an audit and escheat abandoned property”. |
| Siemens USA Holdings v. Geisenberger (3d Cir. Nov. 4, 2021) | “After a near-decade-long audit process”, Delaware ended the holder's expedited examination. “That termination reverted Siemens’s audit to the ordinary examination program, putting interest and penalties back on the table.” | The court sent the case back: “we will vacate and remand”. An expedited exam can be terminated at the State Escheator's discretion, so meet every deadline in the workplan. |
| Univar Solutions v. Geisenberger (D. Del. June 8, 2022) | A holder asked a federal court to stop a Delaware audit subpoena that the Court of Chancery had already enforced. | “For the following reasons, the Court DENIES Plaintiff’s motion.” Subpoenas under 1171(3) are enforceable; challenge scope early and in the right court. |
The Marathon court also described the 2017 law: “the legislature decided to limit the look-back period of all audits to ten years”. The unclaimed property audits guide covers estimation limits in other states, and the which state gets it page covers the priority rules behind the Temple-Inland ruling.
The VDA invitation and the 90-day clock
The invitation is a statutory step, not a courtesy. “The Secretary of State may request, via certified mail or any other commercially reasonable means of correspondence that includes evidence of delivery, that a person enter into an unclaimed property voluntary disclosure agreement”. If the intent form is not received “within 90 days after the request to enter the voluntary disclosure agreement program was delivered, the Secretary of State shall refer the person to the State Escheator for examination” (1173(b)). Within the same 90 days the holder may instead ask the State Escheator to expedite an examination, on the Request to Expedite form.
12 Del. C. 1172(c), 1173(b), (d), (e)(3) and 1185(a)(2); Office of Unclaimed Property enforcement page (2026).
The Secretary of State posts the VDA Invitation Dates: “April 10, 2026” and “August 14, 2026”, “These dates are subject to change.” The Office of Unclaimed Property then follows up. For the spring round, “holders will be able to join the SOS VDA program through July 9, 2026.” After that the door shuts: “holders may not enter the SOS VDA Program after a Notice of Examination has been mailed by the OUP.”
Secretary of State VDA Invitation Dates and Office of Unclaimed Property enforcement page, both read November 21, 2026. Dates are approximate and may change.
An old invitation still counts. The VDA FAQ says “Any company that received at least one letter from the Secretary of State inviting that company into the SOS VDA Program is immediately eligible to be examined under this new statutory provision.” If you find a Secretary of State letter in a predecessor's files, treat the clock as already run, and enroll before an exam notice arrives: “Prior to an examination letter being mailed, companies may still enroll in the SOS VDA Program by completing and submitting Form VDA-1.”
Inside the Secretary of State VDA
Who can enroll. Any holder with property that may be reportable to Delaware, except, among others, “Holders that received an examination notice from the Department of Finance after July 22, 2015.”, holders that withdrew from the program, and holders removed for not working in good faith (1173(e)). Enrollment is by Form VDA-1, signed by an authorized person: “Form VDA-1 may be submitted electronically to sos.vda@delaware.gov.”
Secretary of State, Steps to VDA; 12 Del. C. 1173. Three years of annual reports follow.
Lookback. The holder reviews “starting the first of January for the prior 10 years from when the property is presumed abandoned starting from the calendar year in which the person’s intent to enter into an unclaimed property voluntary disclosure agreement was accepted by the Secretary of State.” (1173(c)(2)). The program puts it in transaction years: “The SOS VDA Period is 10 years plus dormancy from the date the Holder enrolls in the SOS VDA Program.”
Deadline. The agreement and full payment (or a payment plan) are due “within 2 years from the date the person’s intent to enter into an unclaimed property voluntary disclosure agreement was accepted by the Secretary of State.” (1173(d)). The FAQ adds “There is a heavy expectation that enrolled Holders will work diligently to complete the SOS VDA Program as soon as practicable.”
Scope is yours. Under the Secretary of State's estimation rule, 12 DE Admin. Code 301, “The Holder may determine the scope of the entities and property types included in the Department of State Voluntary Disclosure Agreement program.” The release covers only what is in scope; excluded entities and types can be audited.
Estimation in a VDA. Where records are missing, the holder estimates, and Regulation 301 sets the rules:
- Base period: “the base periods utilized by the Holder shall consist of at least the two (2) oldest continuous years the Holder has complete and researchable records outside the dormancy period.”
- Records expected: “seven to eight (7-8) years from the date the Holder voluntarily enrolled” in the program.
- Check aging: “Checks that are outstanding or are voided less than 90 days after issuance shall be excluded from the estimation population.”
- Exclusions: items payable to a federal department or agency, and funds returned in the normal course of business before enrollment.
- AR credits: a review of aged credits and a credit tracing analysis of credits written off a customer's account.
- Priority: “names and addresses identified in the base period shall not be used to determine which state has the priority claim to the abandoned property estimated to be due” over the years with no records.
Program documents are on the Forms and Guidelines page: the Information Request, Scoping Worksheet, Holder Sample Timeline, Holder Sample Work Plan and the SOS VDA Program Guidelines.
Closing and after. The holder signs Form VDA-2; “The Holder will have 10 days to make payment of the amount due.” In return the statute makes the waiver mandatory (“The Secretary of State shall waive interest and penalty under §§ 1183 and 1184 of this title for holders that complete the voluntary disclosure in good faith.”) and the State releases and indemnifies the holder for the property in scope. The audit protection lasts only while the holder keeps filing: “Holder is required to file unclaimed property reports with the Department of Finance (‘DOF’) for the three report years following the completion of the Holder’s abandoned and unclaimed property VDA with the Secretary of State.” Holders in that period “should file a negative (‘zero’) report, if applicable”. See the Post VDA Compliance Requirements.
Verified reports and compliance reviews
Short of an exam, the Office of Unclaimed Property can ask for a verified report or run a compliance review under 1170. The enforcement page explains both. A verified report “is a one-year, limited review of a holder's most recent annual filing or non-filing”; a compliance review is limited to one report and its support, which for most property means “5 years of transactions for most property types that become dormant in Delaware”. No VDA invitation is needed first: “The State Escheator may authorize a compliance review of a report and the notification requirements of § 1172(a) of this title do not apply.”
- Respond fast. “you should acknowledge receipt of the Notice within 30 days”; extensions may run in steps up to 180 days from the notice, but the whole process must finish within a year.
- Notarize. For the verified report form, “Yes, a notarized signature is required.”
- Late property found in the review goes in through the portal, and the current policy is “to waive all interest and penalties for any property voluntarily filed during the Verified Report Process, even if late filed.”
- You can still choose the VDA. The Office “will terminate the Verified Report Process for any holder who enrolls in the VDA Program after receiving a Notice of a Verified Report”.
- Ignoring it leads to referral to the VDA or to enforcement, and 1172(d)(4) lets the State Escheator open an exam without an invitation.
The examination, step by step
Examinations follow the Department of Finance's Regulation 104, the Reporting and Examination Manual adopted in 2017. Its sample Notice of Examination sets the opening moves: the assigned firm “will contact you within the next three weeks”, “It is the State's expectation that an opening conference will be held within ninety days of this notice.”, and the State asks for a records hold “notwithstanding any [Company Name] record retention policies to the contrary”.
- Opening conference. The auditor explains the process, gives a work plan and identifies the maximum period, after asking for tax returns, organization charts, trial balances and the holder's unclaimed property filing history (all states if incorporated in Delaware).
- Scope. Entities and years are set by incorporation dates, lines of business, prior exams and VDAs. “Once entity scoping has been determined by the State, no additional entities may be scoped into the examination without the Holder's consent.”
- Fieldwork. Record requests in writing with reasonable deadlines; the State expects that “the time to complete a typical examination shall not exceed twenty four (24) months.”
- Remediation. “Holders shall be given the opportunity to review, reconcile, remediate and, where applicable under Delaware law, perform due diligence on any items that have been identified as potential unclaimed” property. Outreach letters must be approved by the State first.
- Preliminary findings. “These findings are not final.” The holder gets reasonable time to research and add records.
- Statement of findings. A “complete and unredacted statement of findings” with the property types, the estimation method, the calculation and the findings (1177).
Rebutting an open item. A record of an unpaid debt is prima facie evidence of an obligation, but the holder can overcome it by showing, among other things, that a check “was issued but later was replaced with another instrument because the earlier instrument was lost or contained an error that was corrected.”, or was issued to an affiliate, paid, issued in error or issued without consideration (1175(b)). Keep the documents that prove those facts; they are worth more than any argument.
Estimation in an exam. Regulation 104 requires a larger base than the VDA rule: “In order to draw a representative error rate, the Base Periods utilized shall consist of at least three (3) years from the universe of complete and researchable records.” Sampling targets a sample mean “within 10% of the population mean for that strata at a 90% confidence interval”. Checks outstanding under 90 days and checks voided within 30 days of issue are left out. An officer signs a representation of which records exist, and the holder “is bound by this representation, absent good cause”.
The expedited examination
A holder under examination, or one answering an invitation, may ask to expedite. It files the State's form with answers to all open requests and “a detailed workplan and schedule for completion of the expedited examination”; the State Escheator decides within 60 days (1172(c)(1)). If accepted, all record requests must come “no later than 18 months after the acceptance of the request to expedite”, and the State must finish and issue an examination report within 2 years (1172(c)(3), (4)). Payment is due by the earlier of 90 days after the findings or 3 years from acceptance, with one extension of up to 180 days (1172(c)(7)).
The interest rule: the statute and the form differ. The 2021 Request to Expedite form says “The State shall waive interest and penalty under 12 Del. C. §§ 1183-84 for a completed expedited Examination.” The statute in force says “Interest must be 1% per incident for any holder who receives a notice of examination after August 1, 2021, who completes and remits payment pursuant to a Department of Finance expedited examination process” (1185(a)(2)). The statute governs: plan on 1 percent of the total liability, not zero. The termination risk is real; the form makes it “within the complete discretion of the State Escheator”, and in Siemens a terminated expedited exam reverted to the regular program with full interest exposure.
VDA or examination: side by side
| Secretary of State VDA | Expedited examination | Regular examination | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who runs it | Secretary of State, with its administrator | State Escheator, with a contract auditor | State Escheator, with a contract auditor |
| Who does the work | The holder's own self-review | The auditor, on an agreed workplan | The auditor |
| Lookback | 10 report years plus dormancy from enrollment | 10 years after the duty arose (1172(h)) | 10 years after the duty arose (1172(h)) |
| Estimation base | At least the 2 oldest continuous years with complete records (Reg. 301) | At least 3 years (Reg. 104) | At least 3 years (Reg. 104) |
| Interest and penalties | Waived for good faith completion (1173(a)(1)) | 1% per incident (1185(a)(2)) | At least 20% per incident (1185(a)(1)) |
| Time limit | 2 years from acceptance (1173(d)) | Report within 2 years; payment within 3 (1172(c)) | About 24 months expected (Reg. 104) |
| Afterward | 3 years of annual reports to keep the release | Statement of findings; appeal rights | Statement of findings; appeal rights |
The audit and VDA readiness checklist lists the records to pull together before either path, and the unclaimed property VDA page compares Delaware's program with other states'.
Findings, appeal and records
The statement of findings becomes final unless the holder acts. “Ninety days after the date on which the State Escheator mails a statement of findings and request for payment, it shall constitute the State Escheator’s final determination” of liability. Within those 90 days the holder may sue in the Court of Chancery, or pay and sue for a refund (1179(b)). The court checks whether the findings were “the product of an orderly and logical deductive process rationally supported by substantial, competent evidence on the hearing record.”, reviews law de novo and hears constitutional questions about the exam (1179(d)).
Interest after an exam. The State Escheator may waive for good cause, but for holders noticed after August 1, 2021, “interest must be no less than 20% per incident”, where “‘per incident’ means the total past-due examination liability, including any estimated liability” (1185(a)). Regulation 104 lists what counts toward good cause: “whether the Holder has a significant history of filing unclaimed property reports; the responsiveness of a Holder during the examination; and whether the Holder used ordinary business care in its compliance efforts.” No waiver is allowed for an exam started on a whistleblower's information.
Records. Exam and VDA records are confidential and not public records, and they “may not be used in a joint examination conducted with another state, the United States, a foreign country or subordinate unit of a foreign country, or any other governmental entity unless the person subject to examination consents to such use in writing.” (1174(3)). The holder can ask for them (1174(6)). See the audit notice page for what to do in the first weeks after a notice arrives.
Questions holders ask
How long do I have to answer a Delaware VDA invitation?
90 days from delivery. Send a signed Form VDA-1 to enroll, or ask the State Escheator to expedite an examination. With no answer, the Secretary of State refers you for examination.
Can I join the Delaware VDA after an audit notice?
No. Once the Office of Unclaimed Property mails a Notice of Examination, the Secretary of State may not enter a VDA with that holder (12 Del. C. 1173(e)(3)), except for certain pre-2015 exams converted under 1172(b).
How far back does a Delaware VDA go?
10 report years plus the dormancy period from enrollment: about 15 transaction years for 5-year property such as vendor checks.
Does a Delaware expedited exam waive interest?
The statute sets interest at 1 percent per incident for a completed expedited exam (1185(a)(2)). The 2021 request form says interest and penalties are waived; the statute governs.
Can Delaware estimate my liability if I kept my records?
Not without your written consent, if you filed all required reports and kept the records 1145 requires (1172(f)). Estimation applies to periods with missing records.
Is a Delaware compliance review an audit?
No. It is a limited review of one report under 12 Del. C. 1170, finished within a year, and it does not require a VDA invitation first. You can still enroll in the VDA during one.
Sources
- 12 Del. C. 1145, 1170 to 1179 and 1185: delcode.delaware.gov; Senate Bill 13, 81 Del. Laws c. 1 (2017)
- 12 DE Admin. Code 104 (Department of Finance) and 12 DE Admin. Code 301 (Secretary of State VDA estimation)
- Office of Unclaimed Property: enforcement page, Request to Expedite (2021); Secretary of State: Steps to VDA, VDA FAQs, invitation dates, post VDA requirements
- Court decisions (govinfo): Temple-Inland (2016), Plains (2017), Marathon (2017), Office Depot (2018), Siemens (2021), Univar (2022)